• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Caffè Vergnano 1882: Authentic Italian Coffee & Pastries in NYC’s Eataly

Caffè Vergnano 1882, nestled in New York’s Eataly at 200 5th Ave, offers an authentic Italian coffee experience in a cozy setting. Renowned for expertly crafted espresso shots and rich, non-milk coffee drinks, it captures Italy’s timeless café culture. Highlights include delicate pastries like croissants and tiramisu, alongside savory options such as charcuterie and verdura, making it perfect for quick breaks or casual lunches. Their attention to quality extends to whole beans sold and ground to order. Welcoming and reasonably priced, this spot balances traditional flavors with a modern NYC vibe, making each visit a comforting, flavorful escape.

Caffè Vergnano 1882 at a glance

  • Address 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, United States
  • Phone +1 212-229-2560
  • Restaurant type Coffee shop , Cafe , Espresso bar .
  • Popular for Breakfast , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Caffè Vergnano 1882: Reviews & Ratings

Christina Hilldagoo
5

This is one of the best Milojas I’ve tasted and I’ve had my fair share over the years. They were my dad’s favorite.

Howard
5

Awesome coffee! It's a small booth inside Eataly (Flatiron) and just past the very solid coffee offering from Caffe Lavazza, but this stall only does non-milk espresso drinks. Great shots and an expert barista. It could be an elitist coffee-snob spot, but is actually very friendly and welcoming.

Molly Chen
4

Nice place in Eataly for morning quick coffees lunch break……

Haley B
5

Step out of NYC and into an Authentic Italian Caffe with delicious food and drinks.

Edward M
5

Nice spot for a great coffee. Reasonably priced for NYC despite being in a prime tourist spot. They also sell whole beans and grind to order and have a few options to choose from.

Serdar N
5

I have been to places. I drank coffee in many countries, many caffes and restaurants. This Caffe, you wouldn’t expect a Caffe inside Eataly to be that outstanding, makes the best espresso I had. I chatted with the barista, Miguel, a young and friendly guy, and asked him about his secret. Humble as he was, he blamed it on the coffee and machine. I think it was his magic hands. The desserts are tasty, and seating is pretty comfortable. Too many places you can drink espresso or coffee on New York City. But once tried this one, you won’t enjoy anything else. That’s the only downside.

Andrew Kelly
4

Excellent coffee and perfect for that quick caffeine fix you need whilst walking around Eataly. The stand up bar reminds me perfectly of espresso bars in Italy. The adjoining treatie bar has a tasty treat for every sweet tooth.

Facu Barrionuevo
5

I tried a Flat White and was great! I love the atmosphere, I will have to came back to have dinner in some of the places around!

Location

  • Caffè Vergnano 1882
    Caffè Vergnano 1882
    200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, United States Hotline: +1 212-229-2560

Located in the heart of New York’s Flatiron District at 200 5th Ave, Caffè Vergnano 1882 brings an authentic slice of Italian coffee culture to the city’s vibrant food scene. Nestled inside Eataly, this charming coffee shop offers more than just your average brew; it’s a destination for those who appreciate expertly crafted espresso shots served by skilled baristas in a welcoming, unpretentious setting.

The menu at Caffè Vergnano 1882 delights with a refined selection of Italian staples and innovative treats. Their Mixed Small Things plate is perfect for sharing, combining savory and sweet bites that balance flavor and texture. The Croissant here is flaky and buttery, ideal alongside a rich Latte or a sharp, smooth Espresso Martini for an afternoon pick-me-up. For dessert enthusiasts, the Tiramisu stands out—a luscious tribute to classic Italian pastries that customers like Christina Hilldagoo praise as one of the best around, touching on nostalgia and quality in every bite.

What sets Caffè Vergnano 1882 apart is not just the quality but the atmosphere. Haley B’s words capture it perfectly: stepping inside feels like escaping the bustle of NYC to enjoy a genuine Italian caffe experience. Whether grabbing a quick coffee with Molly Chen or browsing their carefully curated selection of whole beans and in-house grinding options, customers find an inviting, authentic vibe coupled with excellent service.

For those seeking a true espresso-centric experience, this spot’s focus on non-milk espresso drinks offers a finely tuned coffee journey. Howard’s praise highlights the barista’s expertise, ensuring every shot is pulled with precision and care. Edward M notes the reasonable pricing, especially given its prime tourist location, making it a practical yet delicious choice for locals and visitors alike.

In sum, Caffè Vergnano 1882 is more than a coffee shop—it’s a refined yet friendly haven for anyone passionate about Italian coffee and cuisine. The harmony of classic flavors like the Semla and Pâtisserie items with expertly brewed coffee crafts a deeply satisfying experience that invites you to savor each moment and each bite.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Service options
    • Takeout
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments